10 May, 2007

A Trotskyite at the Heritage Foundation

Posted by: Rob Bluey In: Capitol Hill



stollerMatt_5027-1, originally uploaded by matthewnstoller.

This morning at the Heritage Foundation, I hosted a panel discussion about the Open House Project, an effort by the Sunlight Foundation to bring greater transparency to the House of Representatives. Panelists included John Wonderlich of Sunlight, former congressional staffer David All and Matt Stoller of the liberal blog MyDD. We had a small but engaged crowd that asked some insightful questions. I hope everyone who joined us in person and watched online found it interesting and enlightening.

I joked with Stoller before we started that I had to edit his bio . Little did I know that my friend Josh Trevino was already taking issue with my inviting Stoller to speak. In a post on his blog yesterday, Trevino writes:

My movement colleague Rob Bluey, who is heading up this event, is a good and generous man, who shows his better nature in inviting a left-wing hack to a right-wing institution. But when other right-wing institutions reach out to leftist luminaries, Stoller pitches a fit: exhibit A being his leadership of the successful campaign to force the cancellation of a Democratic debate on Fox News, the latter being part of the VRWC in Stoller’s mind. The difference between Fox, with its debatable advancement of the GOP, and Heritage, with its definite advancement of the GOP, is simple: Heritage helps advance the cause of one Matthew Stoller.

While I understand Trevino’s concern — and expected to catch flak for inviting Stoller — I stand by my decision. Stoller and I don’t agree on very much, but we do share a common belief that open government benefits both the right and the left. (He was very articulate on that point during today’s discussion; video will be available soon.)

Will I come back to regret my decision? I hope not. The Matt Stoller that I’ve come to know is someone who I’ve been able to work with constructively toward a common goal. Can he been an over-the-top liberal? No doubt. (He called himself a Trotskyite today.) But I’m sure those on the left could say I’m a stubborn and close-minded right-winger.

What I’ve enjoyed so much about the Open House Project is that it has created a dialog where we can stop yelling at one another and start conversing in a more civil manner. I can only hope that continues, not only on this project but others as well.

UPDATE — 3:50 p.m.: David All responds on techRepublican.

5 Responses to "A Trotskyite at the Heritage Foundation"

1 | joshua.trevi√±o.at » Blog Archive

May 10th, 2007 at 12:35 pm

Avatar

[...] time: Rob Bluey responds. I still think he’s way too optimistic about Stoller’s character. In a just world, [...]

3 | Matt N.

May 10th, 2007 at 3:54 pm

Avatar

There is a fine line between Trotskyism and Neoconservatism, wouldn’t you agree? In fact, I think it would be fascinating to have Trotskyites discuss their differences and similarities with a number of opinions held by certain Weekly Standard columnists. But is Stoller really a Trotskyite?

Anyway, I give you a lot of credit for inviting people from the other side of the ideological spectrum.

4 | Coalitions, friends, enemies « Krempasky.com

May 10th, 2007 at 4:28 pm

Avatar

[...] to coalition work with the online left, as he calls them. Two subjects of his piece, David All and Robert Bluey respond at their [...]

5 | Bluey Blog | Robert B. Bluey » Dick Durbin’s One-Sided Legislation

July 25th, 2007 at 9:39 am

Avatar

[...] Matt Stoller and Chris Bowers have some great ideas for their Open Left website. Designed to serve as the destination for left-wing ideology, it already seems to be off to a good start just a few weeks after launching. The fact that a U.S. senator decided to use the site as a way to solicit feedback about legislation doesn’t exactly happen every day. [...]

Comment Form

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Flickr PhotoStream

  • Inside the House of Blues DallasHouse of Blues DallasHouse of Blues DallasTexas School Book Depository

BlueyTube


FriendFeed

Just saw two helicopters flying over Thurmont, MD. I wonder if the Obamas are visiting Camp David?

Wednesday 17:33

@rorycooper Thanks for hosting the Bloggers Briefing today. I heard it went well. Appreciate your help! #tbb

Wednesday 17:33

Interesting political ad on a Massachusetts gas pump. http://yfrog.com/179wij

Wednesday 17:33

@Gundisalvus has an excellent commentary on Sotomayor and racial identity politics. Highly recommend. http://bit.ly/wBowV

Wednesday 17:33

I blame Obama for all this road work. Stupid stimulus. http://yfrog.com/0jxxtbj

Wednesday 17:33

What idiot decided it was a good idea to do road work on the George Washington Parkway midday Friday? http://yfrog.com/15rsjj

Wednesday 17:33

@MelissaTweets Nope, I'm in Atlanta. Don't think there's a Chick-fil-A at Reagan.

Wednesday 17:33

Took a detour to terminal A. Nothing is better than a Chick-fil-A chicken biscuit for breakfast. http://yfrog.com/0vgjyj

Wednesday 17:33

Great event tonight in Atlanta. Made even better by two friends who attended: @ewerickson and @estherclark. Thanks for coming out!

Wednesday 17:33