28 Jun, 2007

This Time It’s Dead

Posted by: Rob Bluey In: Capitol Hill

President Bush tested conservatives once and lost. He didn’t fare much better the second time. And so goes the story of the ill-conceived immigration bill.

Nearly three weeks ago, after the bill failed a key cloture vote, I wrote that it wasn’t dead yet. This time it is. Today’s vote — which fell 14 short hitting 60 — was a demonstration of the impact that Americans can have on their government.

From the start back in May, this debate was about the Washington elite vs. the grassroots. Today the grassroots won and democracy prevailed.

UPDATE — 12:20 p.m.: I’m told the key votes today came from Senators Jeff Bingaman (D.-N.M.), Sharrod Brown (D.-Ohio), Richard Burr (R.-N.C.), Saxby Chambliss (R.-Ga.), Norm Coleman (R.-Minn.), Susan Collins (R.-Maine), Pete Domenici (R.-N.M.), Mary Landrieu (D.-La.), Mitch McConnell (R.-Ky.), Lisa Murkowski (R.-Alaska), Ben Nelson (D.-Neb.), Mark Pryor (D.-Ark.), Bernie Sanders (I.-Vt.), Richard Shelby (R.-Ala.), George Voinovich (R.-Ohio), John Warner (R.-Va.) and Jim Webb (D.-Va.). Sen. Sam Brownback (R.-Kan.) was also crucial. He actually switched from an ‚Äúaye‚Äù during the vote.

UPDATE — 5:38 p.m.: Heritage Foundation President Ed Feulner comments on today’s vote. “America has always been a nation of laws, as well as a nation of immigrants. In rejecting amnesty for illegal immigrants, today’s Senate vote was a victory for those who believe in the rule of law,” he said.

2 Responses to "This Time It’s Dead"

1 | Bluey Blog | Robert B. Bluey » A Way Forward on Immigration Reform

June 28th, 2007 at 11:07 pm

Avatar

[...] we close the book on the comprehensive immigration bill, it’s important that we don’t put it on the shelf [...]

2 | Bluey Blog | Robert B. Bluey » An Interview With Sen. Lamar Alexander

July 2nd, 2007 at 9:27 am

Avatar

[...] capped a busy week for Alexander. During our interview, we touched on the defeat of the immigration bill, Jim Nussle’s confirmation as OMB director, and the prospects for reauthorizing No Child Left [...]

Comment Form

Flickr PhotoStream

  • Minority Whip Roy Blunt at GOP presser on House floor protest
  • View of the House floor during GOP protest
  • View of the House floor during GOP protest
  • Rep. Pete Hoekstra on House floor during protest

BlueyTube


FriendFeed

@ericarhendry I wondering if any Ithacan people were on Twitter. Let me know if there's anyone else from IC that I should be following.

Wednesday 17:33

@JonHenke We bought ours at Pottery Barn. Check out the Bedford collection. http://is.gd/2iqH

Wednesday 17:33

http://twitpic.com/agun - There's literally a river flowing through my backyard. #hanna

Wednesday 17:33

Favorited 40 videos

Running with Rudy in San Diego Running with Rudy in San Diego Housing Loan Crisis Requires Proper Response Housing Loan Crisis Requires Proper Response Petraeus Testimony Background Petraeus Testimony Background Vlog 7: Surprise Visitor/Academic Apprehension Vlog 7: Surprise Visitor/Academic Apprehension HamNation: Out-Truthing the Truthers HamNation: Out-Truthing the Truthers NCLB Reauthorization Debate and Analysis NCLB Reauthorization Debate and Analysis This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling Mayor Giuliani Reacts To President Bush's Speech Mayor Giuliani Reacts To President Bush's Speech YouTube: Where the Conservatives At? YouTube: Where the Conservatives At? Poverty in America: Rhetoric vs. Reality Poverty in America: Rhetoric vs. Reality Military Deployment Restrictions Is A Bad Idea Military Deployment Restrictions Is A Bad Idea Rediscover Your Party: Episode 2 Rediscover Your Party: Episode 2 HamNation Gets Grassroots HamNation Gets Grassroots New Hampshire GOP FOX News Debate in 10 Minutes New Hampshire GOP FOX News Debate in 10 Minutes Intro to Parties I: The Dish on the Democrats Intro to Parties I: The Dish on the Democrats TMR - CNBC - Reynolds and Levin Debate Tax Increases TMR - CNBC - Reynolds and Levin Debate Tax Increases This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling Family Facts for September Family Facts for September Fred Thompson Announces his Candidacy for President Fred Thompson Announces his Candidacy for President

Wednesday 17:33

@jeffq73 Love the Fish Market. We've never had Pops. Always go to the Scoop across the street. Do you have a preference?

Wednesday 17:33