25 Jul, 2007

Democrats Abandon Transparency for Earmarks

Posted by: Rob Bluey In: Capitol Hill

Weren’t Democrats supposed to bring honesty, ethics and openness to Congress? That was Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s promise upon taking control. But after a little more than six months on the job, the new majority is going back on its word. Transparency on earmarks appears to be just a farce.

In each house of Congress, Democrats are showing signs of returning to business as usual. In the Senate, Majority Leader Harry Reid has been holding up the ethics reform package because he wants to strip it of a earmark transparency provision that he and 97 other senators voted for in January.

Despite facing pressure from his own leadership, conservative Sen. Jim DeMint (R.-S.C.) won’t relent, insisting the language be preserved. It’s causing all sorts of headaches for Reid, who is now facing criticism from liberal advocacy groups that don’t like the fact he refuses to release the text of the legislation.

The dirty little secret on Capitol Hill is that the text of the legislation was written months ago by a handful of people in a smoke-filled room. That’s right. A bill that’s supposed to bring ethics reform to Congress is itself antithetical to transparency.

Trouble is that Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R.-Ky.) might just go along with it. According to Roll Call ($), conservatives fear that the consequences of Republican capitulation could be devastating. “For our leadership to vote against earmark reform and be AWOL on this debate is no way to win back the majority,” one conservative staffer told the newspaper.

Meanwhile, another Democrat in the House, Appropriations Chairman David Obey, is complicating life for anyone who wants to see the earmarks in the Labor-HHS-Education spending bill. Congressional Quarterly reported yesterday that the bill “contained a list of earmarks and their sponsors — but not dollar amounts.” It took some intensive work by an intrepid CQ reporter to discover 420 lawmakers made out with $282.1 million in pork-barrel projects.

Obey may have provided the information required under House rules, but he certainly didn’t do so in a form that was usable. Such disregard for transparency ultimately tarnishes Pelosi’s image. It’s her House. She should make every attempt to uphold her commitment to honesty, ethics and openness.

2 Responses to "Democrats Abandon Transparency for Earmarks"

1 | new fan

July 25th, 2007 at 2:12 pm

Avatar

You seem to be an unvarnished source of deep analytical thought regarding the machinations of the US legislature. I am glad I happened upon you I am going to make sure to come everyday for soberly engineered critical thought and non-partisan thingamajiggery.

A new fan

2 | The Foundry ¬ª Blog Archive » Pelosi Formally Rejects GOP’s Earmark Moratorium

February 6th, 2008 at 11:19 pm

Avatar

[...] instituted tough new rules related to earmarks and cut the number in half. Her first assertion has been challenged by conservatives such as Sens. Tom Coburn and Jim DeMint because the rules don’t go nearly [...]

Comment Form

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Flickr PhotoStream

  • Inside the House of Blues DallasHouse of Blues DallasHouse of Blues DallasTexas School Book Depository

BlueyTube


FriendFeed

Just saw two helicopters flying over Thurmont, MD. I wonder if the Obamas are visiting Camp David?

Wednesday 17:33

@rorycooper Thanks for hosting the Bloggers Briefing today. I heard it went well. Appreciate your help! #tbb

Wednesday 17:33

Interesting political ad on a Massachusetts gas pump. http://yfrog.com/179wij

Wednesday 17:33

@Gundisalvus has an excellent commentary on Sotomayor and racial identity politics. Highly recommend. http://bit.ly/wBowV

Wednesday 17:33

I blame Obama for all this road work. Stupid stimulus. http://yfrog.com/0jxxtbj

Wednesday 17:33

What idiot decided it was a good idea to do road work on the George Washington Parkway midday Friday? http://yfrog.com/15rsjj

Wednesday 17:33

@MelissaTweets Nope, I'm in Atlanta. Don't think there's a Chick-fil-A at Reagan.

Wednesday 17:33

Took a detour to terminal A. Nothing is better than a Chick-fil-A chicken biscuit for breakfast. http://yfrog.com/0vgjyj

Wednesday 17:33

Great event tonight in Atlanta. Made even better by two friends who attended: @ewerickson and @estherclark. Thanks for coming out!

Wednesday 17:33