10 Sep, 2007

Prejudging Petraeus

Posted by: Rob Bluey In: Capitol Hill| Foreign Affairs

Later this afternoon, Gen. David Petraeus and Ambassador Ryan Crocker will testify before Congress about progress in Iraq. Both are expected to cite the reduction in violence as a result of the “surge” and speak about the difficult political situation facing the country. Kirk Johnson, formerly the deputy director for assessments at the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad, outlined the four things you can expect to hear today.

1. The “surge” has been effective at reducing civilian casualty rates, especially in Baghdad.

2. Engaging local tribal leaders and provincial leaders has been effective not only in aiding security but also in improving local governance.

3. Iran continues to train and equip insurgents in Iraq.

4. A withdrawal of U.S. troops at this time would spark a humanitarian disaster.

Kirk told me this morning that he wouldn’t be surprised to see war critics focus on the GAO report that painted a dim picture of the situation in Iraq. However, he cautioned about reading too much into its findings. The benchmarks Congress set for the Iraqi government take a top-down view, Kirk said, but many successes have come from the bottom up, as evidenced by the changing dynamics in Anbar and Diyala.

Anti-war advocates who want our troops out immediately fail to recognize that political progress does not happen overnight, he told me. Kirk cited our own development as a country and the years it took to form our government. He noted this quote from Crocker, his former boss:

After 35 years of injustice under Saddam Hussein, there are some problems since liberation and the problems of 40 years cannot be solved in a year or two. What is important is that there is progress.

Republicans on Capitol Hill, meanwhile, have stepped up their defense of Petraeus even before his testimony. After dozens of stories emerged over the weekend of liberals’ bashing Petraeus, the GOP has started hitting back. My colleagues at RedState want you to help by calling a targeted list of congressmen.

UPDATE — 5:07 p.m.: I’ve updated this post with the ad that’s causing so much controversy on Capitol Hill. Members of Congress have expressed outrage at MoveOn’s tactics.

No Responses to "Prejudging Petraeus"

Comment Form

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Flickr PhotoStream

  • Inside the House of Blues DallasHouse of Blues DallasHouse of Blues DallasTexas School Book Depository

BlueyTube


FriendFeed

Just saw two helicopters flying over Thurmont, MD. I wonder if the Obamas are visiting Camp David?

Wednesday 17:33

@rorycooper Thanks for hosting the Bloggers Briefing today. I heard it went well. Appreciate your help! #tbb

Wednesday 17:33

Interesting political ad on a Massachusetts gas pump. http://yfrog.com/179wij

Wednesday 17:33

@Gundisalvus has an excellent commentary on Sotomayor and racial identity politics. Highly recommend. http://bit.ly/wBowV

Wednesday 17:33

I blame Obama for all this road work. Stupid stimulus. http://yfrog.com/0jxxtbj

Wednesday 17:33

What idiot decided it was a good idea to do road work on the George Washington Parkway midday Friday? http://yfrog.com/15rsjj

Wednesday 17:33

@MelissaTweets Nope, I'm in Atlanta. Don't think there's a Chick-fil-A at Reagan.

Wednesday 17:33

Took a detour to terminal A. Nothing is better than a Chick-fil-A chicken biscuit for breakfast. http://yfrog.com/0vgjyj

Wednesday 17:33

Great event tonight in Atlanta. Made even better by two friends who attended: @ewerickson and @estherclark. Thanks for coming out!

Wednesday 17:33