03 Oct, 2007

White House Catches Nancy Pelosi in a Lie

Posted by: Rob Bluey In: Capitol Hill



Speaker Nancy Pelosi, originally uploaded by AFSCME.org.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and Caucus Chairman Rahm Emanuel (D-Ill.) spent the day spinning President Bush’s veto of the $35-billion expansion of SCHIP. In some cases, uneducated reporters failed to question their outrageous assertions. Fortunately, Republicans aren’t letting the Democrats get away with it.

Rep. Eric Cantor (R-Va.) left Emanuel speechless during a TV debate this afternoon. And when I asked Rep. Mike Pence (R-Ind.) if Emanuel would successfully woo 15 Republicans to override the veto, Pence said his Democrat colleague was blowing smoke. “I think he‚Äôs talking through his hat,” Pence said.

Now I’m pleased to see the White House is challenging Pelosi on three misleading statements she made about SCHIP today.

1) Pelosi said he bill is “just enrolling all of the children who are eligible” and not “expanding an eligibility” for SCHIP. That’s a bald-faced lie, according to the White House.

• There are hundreds of thousands of children eligible for SCHIP under current law who are not signed up for the program. SCHIP was created to cover children in families with annual incomes at or below 200 percent of the Federal poverty level.

‚Ä¢ Congress’ bill explicitly rejects a requirement that 95 percent of eligible children from families with incomes under 200 percent of the poverty level must be enrolled in SCHIP before children in higher-income families can be covered.

‚Ä¢ Congress’ bill would also allow SCHIP to cover children in some households with incomes of up to $83,000 per year ‚Äì 400 percent of the Federal poverty level.

2) Pelosi said the bill was “about private medicine.” Yeah right, says the White House.

‚Ä¢ Under Congress’ plan, one out of every three additional children moving onto government coverage would be moving from private insurance. Of the approximately 6 million enrollees Congress’ legislation would attract by 2012, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that 2 million would drop private insurance to enroll.

‚Ä¢ The policies of the government ought to be helping people get private insurance, not Federal coverage. That’s why the President believes strongly in Association Health Plans to help small business owners better afford insurance for their workers and believes we ought to change the Federal tax code to help individuals better afford insurance in the marketplace.

3) Pelosi said Bush “missed an opportunity to say to the children of America, your health and well-being are important to us.” She obviously didn’t listen close enough.

‚Ä¢ Today, President Bush reiterated his strong support for SCHIP. THE PRESIDENT: “I strongly support the program. I like the idea of helping those who are poor be able to get health coverage for their children. I supported it as governor, and I support it as President of the United States.”

‚Ä¢ This year, the Administration will spend about $35.5 billion to provide health insurance for poor children through Medicaid. THE PRESIDENT: “In other words, when they say, ‘Well, poor children aren’t being covered in America,’ if that’s what you’re hearing on your TV screens, I’m telling you there’s $35.5 billion worth of reasons not to believe that.”

5 Responses to "White House Catches Nancy Pelosi in a Lie"

1 | Bluey Blog | Robert B. Bluey » Harry Reid Slams the Door on SCHIP Negotiations

October 4th, 2007 at 8:05 pm

Avatar

[...] Democrats are using SCHIP to score political points against Republicans. Speaker Nancy Pelosi was caught lying about the program yesterday and now Reid is refusing to even talk about a solution. This is the sad state of [...]

2 | Jenny Bea

October 5th, 2007 at 9:30 am

Avatar

Gee if only they’d call her on all the other ridiculous things she says.

3 | Chet Randolph

October 5th, 2007 at 10:03 am

Avatar

Paul Krugman has a great column today about this, and the “f– you” mentality of the GOP. If you’re sick, if you’re poor, if you’re hit by a hurricane; the GOP not only says “f– you” - even to our country’s children! Not only that, they’re so craven they make jokes about it! Yeah, it’s hysterical that there are 3.8 million children with no health coverage, while Bush asks for another $190 billion to piss away on a war that makes America LESS safe. Heckuva job, Bushie!

The other thing about this, and it’s something none of our “punditry” every points out, is when Bush makes bizarre statements like “if that‚Äôs what you‚Äôre hearing on your TV screens”. Why does this moron talk like he’s 90 years old and TV, or “the internets”, are some new fangled thing? Does he really think that by talking dumb, he can escape his blue-blood, elitist, child-of-priviledge upbringing? He’s acts like he’s from some rustic backround, and not the ivy league preppy schools of New England.

4 | sidney upsher

October 5th, 2007 at 12:31 pm

Avatar

The democratic leadership has no interest in the health of poor children unless they can serve as bait to promote this sly attempt to advance the cause of socialized medicine and advance their bid to win in 2008. The confirmation is their rejection of Bush’s offer to negotiate.

5 | Funky P

October 6th, 2007 at 10:46 am

Avatar

I am unable to detect the lie you claim for Ms. Pelosi.
And, after watching the highly edited clip of Cantor/Emmanuel I fail to see how Emmanuel was ‘left speechless’. How about providing an UNEDITED clip of the debate so we can decide for ourselves?
This is about priorities. How is it that so-called ‘right to life’ republicans can argue against healthcare, while asserting the need to continue to fund the failed war in Iraq?
Who has a right to life? From the Republican perspective, white wealthy Americans come first!

Comment Form

Flickr PhotoStream

  • Minority Whip Roy Blunt at GOP presser on House floor protest
  • View of the House floor during GOP protest
  • View of the House floor during GOP protest
  • Rep. Pete Hoekstra on House floor during protest

BlueyTube


FriendFeed

@ericarhendry I wondering if any Ithacan people were on Twitter. Let me know if there's anyone else from IC that I should be following.

Wednesday 17:33

@JonHenke We bought ours at Pottery Barn. Check out the Bedford collection. http://is.gd/2iqH

Wednesday 17:33

http://twitpic.com/agun - There's literally a river flowing through my backyard. #hanna

Wednesday 17:33

Favorited 40 videos

Running with Rudy in San Diego Running with Rudy in San Diego Housing Loan Crisis Requires Proper Response Housing Loan Crisis Requires Proper Response Petraeus Testimony Background Petraeus Testimony Background Vlog 7: Surprise Visitor/Academic Apprehension Vlog 7: Surprise Visitor/Academic Apprehension HamNation: Out-Truthing the Truthers HamNation: Out-Truthing the Truthers NCLB Reauthorization Debate and Analysis NCLB Reauthorization Debate and Analysis This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling Mayor Giuliani Reacts To President Bush's Speech Mayor Giuliani Reacts To President Bush's Speech YouTube: Where the Conservatives At? YouTube: Where the Conservatives At? Poverty in America: Rhetoric vs. Reality Poverty in America: Rhetoric vs. Reality Military Deployment Restrictions Is A Bad Idea Military Deployment Restrictions Is A Bad Idea Rediscover Your Party: Episode 2 Rediscover Your Party: Episode 2 HamNation Gets Grassroots HamNation Gets Grassroots New Hampshire GOP FOX News Debate in 10 Minutes New Hampshire GOP FOX News Debate in 10 Minutes Intro to Parties I: The Dish on the Democrats Intro to Parties I: The Dish on the Democrats TMR - CNBC - Reynolds and Levin Debate Tax Increases TMR - CNBC - Reynolds and Levin Debate Tax Increases This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling This Week on the Hill with Brian Darling Family Facts for September Family Facts for September Fred Thompson Announces his Candidacy for President Fred Thompson Announces his Candidacy for President

Wednesday 17:33

@jeffq73 Love the Fish Market. We've never had Pops. Always go to the Scoop across the street. Do you have a preference?

Wednesday 17:33