17 Oct, 2007

Republicans Rally Around SCHIP Alternative

Posted by: Rob Bluey In: Capitol Hill

As Democrats stage the ultimate political stunt Thursday with an override vote of President Bush’s SCHIP veto, Republicans are actually planning to do something about saving the children’s health care program.

Sens. Mel Martinez (R-Fla.) and George Voinovich (R-Ohio) will join Reps. Marilyn Musgrave (R-Colo.), Tom Price (R-Ga.), Tom Feeney (R-Fla.) and Tim Walberg (R-Mich.) to introduce an alternative to the Democrats’ $35-billion expansion. The lawmakers plan an afternoon news conference in the Capitol around the time of the veto vote.

Their alternative, based on a proposal crafted by the Heritage Foundation, consists of three elements:

1) A full reauthorization of SCHIP. The program would continue to cover children in families with incomes at or below 200% of the federal poverty level;

2) A child health care tax credit. Rather than putting more people on a government-run program, the legislation advances tax credits to families with incomes between 200% and 300% of the poverty level; and

3) A health care “federalism” initiative. This piece would complement both the reauthorization and the tax changes in expanding health care coverage, and would encourage even more dramatic health care experimentation at the state level with different approaches to coverage expansion.

Democrats, including Speaker Nancy Pelosi, have supported the idea of a tax credit, and others, such as Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D-N.M.) and Rep. Tammy Baldwin (D-Wis.), have offered legislation supporting the “federalism” approach.

Martinez has been working on the plan prior to Bush’s veto. Unfortunately, Democrats have been so intent on politicizing SCHIP that few have considered actually talking to Republicans about about an alternative approach. Now that the Democrats’ intense lobbying appears certain to fail, Republicans hope their approach could sway liberals to come to the table.

21 Responses to "Republicans Rally Around SCHIP Alternative"

2 | Republicans Introduce SCHIP Alternative : The American Pundit

October 18th, 2007 at 9:29 am

Avatar

[...] this is interesting. Rob Bluey reports that Republicans are rallying around an alternative to the massive Democratic expansion of SCHIP. [...]

3 | Michelle Malkin » House showdown: The S-CHIP veto override vote

October 18th, 2007 at 10:11 am

Avatar

[...] case you missed it last night, here’s the GOP alternative that will be introduced later [...]

4 | Do Democrats Give a SCHIP About the Children? » Constitutionally Right

October 18th, 2007 at 11:09 am

Avatar

[...] which earn more than the average American, Republicans are finally doing something pro-active. As Rob Bluey is reporting: Sens. Mel Martinez (R-Fla.) and George Voinovich (R-Ohio) will join Reps. Marilyn [...]

5 | madmatt

October 18th, 2007 at 12:00 pm

Avatar

A tax credit for people who are paying minimal taxes and don’t have the cash reserves to pay for healtcare in the first place…another dumb idea from heritage that actually does nothing!

6 | PSMarc

October 18th, 2007 at 1:10 pm

Avatar

The bill Bush vetoed is written and supported by Republicans as well as Democrats. Simply because Bush doesn’t like it does it suddenly become a “democrat” bill. There’s a huge number of Republicans who don’t see him as a leader, and see that even middle class families can be destroyed by health care costs. We need SCHIP expanded.

7 | Rob Bluey

October 18th, 2007 at 1:20 pm

Avatar

Liberal trolls have invaded Bluey Blog! But don’t fear, you’re welcome to spout your gibberish here.

Madmatt says the tax credit won’t work because people “don‚Äôt have the cash reserves to pay for healtcare in the first place.” The families who would get the tax credit earn more than $40,000. And the credit would come in two forms: “a non-refundable tax credit for taxpaying families, and a refundable tax credit (in effect, a voucher) for families that do not pay enough in taxes to secure a credit.”

Another commenter, PSMarc, argues that the bill Bush veto was a bipartisan solutions. While it’s true that Republicans did support the measure, those same moderates also accused Democrats of playing political games by not negotiating.

8 | JayLynn

October 18th, 2007 at 1:20 pm

Avatar

People making between 200 and 300 percent of the poverty level (between 41,000 and 62,000 dollars a year for a family of 4) do not pay enough in taxes to take advantage of a tax credit, so these families would still be paying for their healthcare coverage out of pocket. Furthermore, people with children who have pre-existing conditions and who experience any gap in health insurance coverage are often unable to buy private health insurance at any price. Therefore, this “Republican alternative” to the Schip bill is fundamentally unworkable. Government health insurance covers all children for all reasons, regardless of pre-existing conditions. If the Republicans would get out of the pockets of the private insurance industry long enough to impose reforms on the runaway greed and rampant liberties of these companies, perhaps the general public would be willing to believe that they were really, truly working on a solution and not simply playing politics.

9 | Brent

October 18th, 2007 at 1:31 pm

Avatar

Wow, Bush is willing to spend billions fighting his war, but not willing to actually take care of the youngest citizens in his own country. He is truly scum.

10 | mantis

October 18th, 2007 at 1:40 pm

Avatar

As Democrats stage the ultimate political stunt Thursday with an override vote of President Bush’s SCHIP veto

A veto override vote is “the ultimate political stunt?” Gee, I thought it was one of the procedures enshrined in the Constitution to ensure that there are checks and balances among the branches of government. Silly me.

11 | Bluey Blog | Robert B. Bluey » House Sustains Bush’s SCHIP Veto

October 18th, 2007 at 1:43 pm

Avatar

[...] of Captain’s Quarters blogged about the debate from start to finish. Today at 3 p.m. Republicans will unveil their alternative.  Posted at 1:43 PM in Capitol Hill         Save to [...]

12 | Rob Bluey

October 18th, 2007 at 2:47 pm

Avatar

In the comment above, mantis thinks I’m being too hard on the Democrats. I agree that the act of voting to override isn’t a political stunt in itself, but the shenanigans that people like Rep. Pete Stark pulled on the House floor today certainly qualify.

13 | Rob Bluey

October 18th, 2007 at 2:52 pm

Avatar

In response to JayLynn, I would encourage you to read the proposal before casting it in such an unfavorable manner.

As you’ll see, the tax credit is refundable and advanceable, meaning that even families with little to no tax liability would get the full credit (the refundable piece) AND assistance upfront when premiums are due (the advanceable piece).

Liberal members of Congress, including Rep. Rahm Emanuel earlier this year, have supported giving families between 200% and 350% of the federal poverty level a tax credit.

This isn’t just a conservative or a Republican proposal. It is being offered to bring both sides to the table.

14 | republicans propose S-CHIP alternative :: all-encompassingly :: blog

October 18th, 2007 at 3:06 pm

Avatar

[...] here. Posted by travis in travis, politics | [...]

15 | Bill from Illinois

October 18th, 2007 at 3:18 pm

Avatar

Looks to me like it is just a back door entry for the Liberals to get illegal aliens on the payroll!

16 | UNHINGED « Texas Hold ‘Em Blogger

October 18th, 2007 at 3:53 pm

Avatar

[...] are offering their alternative plan to expand [...]

17 | JABbering Stooge :: S-CHIP veto stands - Dems to fold like lawn chairs :: October :: 2007

October 18th, 2007 at 4:08 pm

Avatar

[...] they’ve got an “alternative” to S-CHIP in the works. And apparently, it’s been written for the Rethuglicans by the right-wing [...]

18 | Iraq .::. The Current Truth About The Iraq War

October 18th, 2007 at 4:44 pm

Avatar

[...] I noted last night, they’ll unveil their SCHIP alternative at 3pm Eastern [...]

19 | mantis

October 18th, 2007 at 5:49 pm

Avatar

I agree that the act of voting to override isn’t a political stunt in itself, but the shenanigans that people like Rep. Pete Stark pulled on the House floor today certainly qualify.

Agreed. What a lunatic.

20 | Pursuit of Liberty ¬ª Blog Archive » SCHIP Numbers

October 19th, 2007 at 4:47 pm

Avatar

[...] there is an alternative solution being proposed in the House that covers those under 200% of the federal poverty level and then gives tax credits for those up [...]

21 | John Ryan

October 22nd, 2007 at 3:04 pm

Avatar

7 Billion per year doesn’t seem like much to keep kids healthy

Comment Form

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Flickr PhotoStream

  • Inside the House of Blues DallasHouse of Blues DallasHouse of Blues DallasTexas School Book Depository

BlueyTube


FriendFeed

Just saw two helicopters flying over Thurmont, MD. I wonder if the Obamas are visiting Camp David?

Wednesday 17:33

@rorycooper Thanks for hosting the Bloggers Briefing today. I heard it went well. Appreciate your help! #tbb

Wednesday 17:33

Interesting political ad on a Massachusetts gas pump. http://yfrog.com/179wij

Wednesday 17:33

@Gundisalvus has an excellent commentary on Sotomayor and racial identity politics. Highly recommend. http://bit.ly/wBowV

Wednesday 17:33

I blame Obama for all this road work. Stupid stimulus. http://yfrog.com/0jxxtbj

Wednesday 17:33

What idiot decided it was a good idea to do road work on the George Washington Parkway midday Friday? http://yfrog.com/15rsjj

Wednesday 17:33

@MelissaTweets Nope, I'm in Atlanta. Don't think there's a Chick-fil-A at Reagan.

Wednesday 17:33

Took a detour to terminal A. Nothing is better than a Chick-fil-A chicken biscuit for breakfast. http://yfrog.com/0vgjyj

Wednesday 17:33

Great event tonight in Atlanta. Made even better by two friends who attended: @ewerickson and @estherclark. Thanks for coming out!

Wednesday 17:33