25 Oct, 2007

Five Reasons Why the SCHIP Bill Still Sets Bad Policy

Posted by: Rob Bluey In: Capitol Hill

Democrats are moving swiftly to pass a new SCHIP bill today in hopes of swaying enough Republicans to ensure a veto-proof margin in the House. The Democrats’ maneuver comes as nearly a dozen Republicans have headed home to California to survey the damage caused by wildfires this week.

The Democrats’ quick response after a losing a vote last week to override President Bush’s veto signals their belief that enough Republicans might swallow the minor changes to the $35-billion expansion of the State Children’s Health Insurance Program.

In reality, however, the new SCHIP bill actually differs little from the version that Bush vetoed. Democrats have made small tweaks, but the bill itself still costs the same and relies on a tobacco tax to fund the expansion. Among the other problem that still remain:

1) It still raises the general federal income eligibility for SCHIP to 300% of the federal poverty level (an increase from the current 200 % level).

2) It still covers adults, just in new ways either directly through Medicaid or through a new funding mechanism (that is more generous than Medicaid).

3) It still crowds-out private coverage. New Congressional Budget Office estimates show that more than 2 million kids would move from private coverage to government coverage.

4) It still expands the program to “new” populations. New CBO estimates show 1.1 million would be newly eligible.

5) It still waters down citizenship verification requirements made in the Deficit Reduction Act.

3 Responses to "Five Reasons Why the SCHIP Bill Still Sets Bad Policy"

1 | Bluey Blog | Robert B. Bluey » Bush Promises to Veto New SCHIP Bill

October 25th, 2007 at 11:46 am

Avatar

[...] Blog - The Official Blog of Robert B. Bluey « Five Reasons Why the SCHIP Bill Still Sets Bad Policy October 25th, [...]

2 | And Rightly So! » S CHIP Dynamics

October 25th, 2007 at 4:32 pm

Avatar

[...] Robert Bluey has a list of 5 reasons this bill is not what the Democrats are claiming: 1) It still raises the general federal income eligibility for SCHIP to 300% of the federal poverty level (an increase from the current 200 % level). [...]

3 | Bluey Blog | Robert B. Bluey » Democrats Lose Ground on SCHIP Vote

October 25th, 2007 at 6:50 pm

Avatar

[...] House floor today as its “old” counterpart. The Democrats’ plan to ram through a slightly modified version of the bill backfired when 141 Republicans stood united to oppose it. The final vote was 265-142, [...]

Comment Form

Flickr PhotoStream

  • Minority Whip Roy Blunt at GOP presser on House floor protest
  • View of the House floor during GOP protest
  • View of the House floor during GOP protest
  • Rep. Pete Hoekstra on House floor during protest

BlueyTube


FriendFeed

Praising the work of @sanuzis and the Michigan GOP. http://tinyurl.com/6ms5mr

Wednesday 17:33

@sorendayton Please let USNews be wrong. I guess I'd take Whitman out of that group, although I know next to nothing about her policy views.

Wednesday 17:33

@Saxby08 Please tell me why you compromised on energy and sold out to Democrats on drilling? http://tinyurl.com/6r5cza #dontgo

Wednesday 17:33

@batterista Fred asked to follow @MelissaBluey the other day. Maybe something is up?

Wednesday 17:33

@justin_hart Good idea on mymanmitt.com. I liked your e-mail pitch, too. Hadn't heard that story about Romney and the pizza party before.

Wednesday 17:33

@rightwingsparkl We need more conservative leaders like Michael Williams.

Wednesday 17:33