30 Dec, 2007

Reconsidering John McCain

Posted by: Rob Bluey In: Politics



John McCain Rally-19, originally uploaded by Michael J Metts.

Few people disliked John McCain more than I did back in May and June, when immigration dominated the headlines and the senator’s support for comprehensive reform nearly sunk his presidential campaign. It’s strange how a few months and a new issue can change one’s perspective. Today I can’t think of a presidential candidate I admire more than McCain for his principled stand against pork-barrel spending, particularly in the wake of the earmark-filled omnibus spending bill.

I’ve come to accept that I will always have a love-hate relationship with McCain. With the first votes of 2008 about to be cast, I’m surprised shocked to see McCain so competitive considering he was left for dead six months ago. I’ve personally gone from wanting McCain out of the race — gloating over his campaign layoffs and rumors of his demise — to valuing his presence perhaps more than any other candidate.

I’m not endorsing any candidate in either party, but I feel comfortable saying that the Republican race wouldn’t be complete without McCain. Take the issues of fiscal restraint and national security, for example. It’s no surprise Rudy and Romney trumpeted their fiscally conservative credentials after passage of the bloated omnibus; McCain has railed against earmarks for years, long before other candidates uttered a word about them. And on foreign policy, there’s no stronger voice than McCain’s. As events of the last week illustrated, McCain’s knowledge and experience give him an advantage over everyone else in the race. His support of the surge in Iraq was a huge gamble, but his principled stand might turn out to be his biggest asset.

While there are issues in McCain’s past that continue to trouble me — campaign finance reform and his mixed record on taxes being two big hurdles — I cannot help but wonder if he’s learned from such mistakes. I certainly don’t expect him to reverse course entirely from previous policy positions, but his response in the aftermath of the immigration debacle gives me hope. Rather than continuing to tout a failed plan, McCain recognized his mistake and endorsed the idea of an enforcement-first approach. Some may call that flip-flopping, but I call it political reality and an attempt to tackle a serious public policy issue.

Putting policy aside, there’s another reason I’ve grown to like John McCain: He’s made himself accessible. Whether it’s at public town hall meetings or through conversations with bloggers by telephone or on his bus, McCain recognizes the importance of relating to ordinary Americans. (Yes, I consider myself one.) At a time when other candidates talk only to elite reporters or packed auditoriums — heck, Mike Huckabee is charging people to hear him speak — McCain seems genuinely interested in people rather than a political script. He’ll give you straight talk anytime or anywhere.

Realistically, I’m not sure McCain stands a chance, even if he does perform well in Iowa and wins New Hampshire. But there’s no question he’s a battle-tested warrior who is going to fight until the end. For that I give him credit.

UPDATE — 10:32 p.m.: Patrick Ruffini e-mails this post, which features an article from Jonathan Chait of The New Republic that was written in 2002.

3 Responses to "Reconsidering John McCain"

1 | Jonathan Rick

December 31st, 2007 at 2:43 pm

Avatar

Love-hate is apt. McCain’s not perfect, but who is? Elections, like all things, are about weighing a candidate’s good against his bad; and even though I disagree with him on significant issues, the reasons you lay out — from McCain’s accessibility to his principledness and opposition to earmarks — make him a very attractive candidate. (Even Rudy thinks so.)

2 | eyeon08.com » links for 2007-12-31

January 1st, 2008 at 2:13 pm

Avatar

[...] Bluey Blog | RobertBluey.com » Reconsidering John McCain (tags: 2008 mccain) [...]

3 | australia

February 7th, 2008 at 12:11 am

Avatar

Voting for McCain is like voting for Bush,are you Americans that thick I cant believe you people.He’s just another war monger like Bush and the rest of the world has be dragged into your bullshit war that you started back in the 90’s and if you had of kept your nose out of other peoples businesses you precious twin towers would still be standing and now we all have to suffer with your actions,you are a bunch of know it all fuck heads.While you all carry on about how great your country is the rest of the world are laughing at you.There should be only one agenda and thats global warming,but that wont happen until a tornado wipes out a major white populated area like chicargo or new york.So you all just keep driving your SUV’s around with heads up your asses.When ever I see an American in Australia I spit on them,you cunts make me so angry. I hope tornado season this year make you people wake up and realize what’s really important.PS don’t come to Australia because we hate you.

Comment Form

Flickr PhotoStream

  • Minority Whip Roy Blunt at GOP presser on House floor protest
  • View of the House floor during GOP protest
  • View of the House floor during GOP protest
  • Rep. Pete Hoekstra on House floor during protest

BlueyTube


FriendFeed

Praising the work of @sanuzis and the Michigan GOP. http://tinyurl.com/6ms5mr

Wednesday 17:33

@sorendayton Please let USNews be wrong. I guess I'd take Whitman out of that group, although I know next to nothing about her policy views.

Wednesday 17:33

@Saxby08 Please tell me why you compromised on energy and sold out to Democrats on drilling? http://tinyurl.com/6r5cza #dontgo

Wednesday 17:33

@batterista Fred asked to follow @MelissaBluey the other day. Maybe something is up?

Wednesday 17:33

@justin_hart Good idea on mymanmitt.com. I liked your e-mail pitch, too. Hadn't heard that story about Romney and the pizza party before.

Wednesday 17:33

@rightwingsparkl We need more conservative leaders like Michael Williams.

Wednesday 17:33